Trust vs Will: Choosing the Right Foundation for Your Estate Plan

Most of us won’t just wake up one morning and say to ourselves, “You know what, I really want to choose whether I have a will or a trust.” More likely, we’ll be asked to consider a much simpler question: Once I’m gone, or once I’ve lost my ability to care for my own affairs, how do I ensure that those who will be left to carry out my wishes will handle everything as I would like it to be handled? This is exactly where wills and trusts enter into our lives. Wills and trusts aren’t competitive tools. 

One does not necessarily surpass the other. The main function of both is simply different. A will provides instruction after your death. A trust allows you to provide for control and continuity before your death and for continued control and continuity after your death. Ultimately, the most effective estate plans combine both – each plan filling the void left by the other.

Key Takeaways

• A will describes what happens to your assets when you die; however, for the administration of those assets to begin (probate), the will must first go through probate.
• A trust may allow management of assets while the grantor is alive, after death, or at any time, which is one reason the assets held in a trust are not usually required to be included in probate.
• Generally, trusts provide greater privacy, longer-term control, and additional flexibility with regard to managing and distributing assets.
• For many simple estates, wills remain an acceptable option and may require far less time and money than establishing a trust.
• In cases where multiple jurisdictions are involved, business ownership, vulnerable parties who may have difficulty protecting their own interests, or ongoing succession planning considerations are present, a combination of a trust and a will may be beneficial.
• Which estate planning strategy is best? It really doesn’t matter how wealthy you are; what matters more are the circumstances of your individual situation, your family dynamics, and your long-term goals.

What Is a Will and How It Works in Estate Planning

It is widely recognized as the cornerstone of effective estate planning, and for many people, it is the most widely recognized estate planning document. A will is a legally binding document that specifies how a person’s estate should be handled after they pass away. 

Typically, a will allows someone (the testator) to appoint an executor, specify who should inherit assets, name guardians for children who are still minors, and leave instructions regarding personal possessions or gifts to charity. Importantly, a will only becomes legally enforceable after the testator has died. During the testator’s lifetime, generally speaking, it does not have authority over how assets are owned or managed.

What a Will Does Well

A properly drafted will allows you to:

• Specify who inherits your assets
• Appoint guardians for minor children
• Name executors to carry out your wishes
• Address personal items with sentimental value

For many individuals with relatively simple estates, a will provides clarity and direction without unnecessary complexity. It is also typically quicker and less expensive to create than a trust.

The majority of jurisdictions recognize the necessity of updating wills after a major event in an individual’s life (such as marriage, divorce, the birth of children, or the acquisition of significant new wealth) to continue to reflect their wishes and comply with applicable law. Also, periodic updates will provide assurance the will remains current and compliant with applicable laws at the time of an individual’s death.

Where Wills Fall Short

Wills, although important components of estate plans, have several built-in limitations; many of these limitations go unnoticed prior to death.

One of the largest limitations is the requirement for probate. Probate is generally defined as the legal process by which the executor obtains authorization to manage the deceased’s estate. Depending on the type of assets owned, probate may be required from financial institutions, land registries, and other investment companies to allow them to release or transfer ownership of those assets. The UK government has published official information regarding whether probate may be required and how the process works.

Similar to the United Kingdom, probate rules in each U.S. state are developed based on local laws; therefore, there is considerable variability among states’ procedures, timelines, and fees associated with the probate process.

Probate is not inherently problematic. In many cases it proceeds smoothly. However, it can introduce:

• Waiting periods before beneficiaries receive assets,
• Additional legal and administrative costs,
• And a level of public exposure that many families would prefer to avoid.

In addition to these limitations, there is another limitation inherent in a will. A will is essentially a final set of directions rather than an ongoing plan. Therefore, while you can specify who will receive your property through a will, you have very few options to direct how your property is handled over time and when it is distributed. Your rights as a testator to direct the management and use of your property also end once the distribution is completed.

These limitations don’t make wills ineffective; they simply define where wills work best and where other tools may be needed.

What Is a Trust and How It Shapes an Estate Plan

A trust operates quite differently from a will. Unlike a will, which takes effect at the time of your death, a trust may be created during your life and continue after your death. By creating a trust, you may specify how you wish your assets to be managed prior to your death.

Assets placed within a trust are typically legally owned by the trustee. The trustee’s function is to manage these assets for the benefit of the beneficiaries as outlined in the trust deed and governing laws. The distinction between legal and beneficial ownership is an essential element of what defines a trust.

Trusts have been utilized in virtually every country with common law systems (England & Wales, the U.S., Australia, and New Zealand) and in international financial centers. However, due to the considerable variation in how trusts are treated in different jurisdictions, it is advisable to seek professional counsel when creating a trust involving international assets or beneficiaries.

How Trusts Work in Practice

There are three primary components to a trust:

• A person known as a “trustee” (or trustees) who manages the property/assets contained within the trust;
• The people who benefit from this trust are referred to as “beneficiaries”;
• There are also typically rules, or language, defining how/when these assets may be utilized/distributed by the trustee(s).

As you see above, because the trust itself owns the assets and the individuals do not, when an individual’s personal situation changes, the trust itself continues to exist and operate accordingly.

Why Trusts Offer More Control

Trusts provide more opportunities for planning than wills. Some examples include:

• A trust can delay distribution of assets until a beneficiary reaches a certain age (i.e., delayed distribution);
• A trust allows for gradual distribution of assets over time rather than distributing them all at one time;
• A trust provides asset protection for the trust assets against poor financial decisions made by the beneficiary;
• A trust preserves continuity of management should the settlor become disabled/incapacitated.

It is for these reasons that trusts are often the focal point in many estate plans regarding business interests, vulnerable beneficiaries, or the goal of preserving wealth across multiple generations.

TRUSTS & FOUNDATIONS
FREE CONSULTATION

on offshore structures and jurisdictions
that would best meet your
asset protection goals.

on offshore structures and jurisdictions that would best meet your asset protection goals.

We’ll contact you in 10 minutes

CLICK TO
BOOK CLICK TO
BOOK

We’ll contact you in 10 minutes

Revocable vs Irrevocable Trusts

Trusts can also vary greatly as to how they function. One of the most significant differences for many people is whether a trust is revocable or irrevocable.

Revocable Trust

Typically, a revocable trust, also known as a living trust, allows the settlor to modify the terms of the trust, including terminating it altogether at any time before death, assuming they still have the legal capability to make such decisions.

Common uses for revocable trusts include:

• Simplifying estate administration;
• Maintaining continuity for the settlor if they become incapacitated;
• Avoidance of probate in certain jurisdictions;
• Protection of privacy over certain assets.

Since the settlor typically has the ability to manage the assets included in a revocable trust, it generally provides less asset protection than an irrevocable trust.

Irrevocable Trust

Generally, an irrevocable trust provides no flexibility regarding changes after it is created. However, there are exceptions permitted by law and/or set forth in the trust document itself.

Irrevocable trusts are typically used when one of the goals includes:

• Long-term asset protection;
• Succession planning;
• Preservation of family wealth;
• Support for vulnerable beneficiaries;
• Tax-planning strategies that are permitted under the law.

There are significant differences in the legal implications and taxes associated with both types of trusts. For example, the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS) will treat each type differently from a tax standpoint. Additionally, other countries may have completely different systems of laws regarding trusts.

Therefore, rather than determining which type of trust is better, a more applicable question would be, “Which type of trust most closely supports the individual’s stated objectives and current legal framework?”

Trust vs Will: A Side-by-Side Comparison

The process of determining if you should create a trust or will is largely about defining how much direction you want in the distribution of your property and when. A will is a series of instructions that only take effect at the time of your death. A trust can direct property management during your lifetime and quietly manage your property after your death. This comparison illustrates why trusts and wills are generally both utilized together rather than separately.

This comparison ultimately suggests that estate planning is not a matter of selecting one tool over another but rather involves using a will as the authority to settle matters and define future directions while using a trust to provide continuity and structure for addressing future concerns. Rather than asking, “Will I utilize a trust or a will?” it is better to determine how each tool can be used effectively to serve the broader purposes of your overall plan. 

In more complex estate plans, trusts and wills are sometimes used alongside additional or alternative structures, for example, Nevis multiform foundations, to manage taxation, succession, or cross-border ownership more efficiently. 

When a Will Alone May Be Enough

It’s possible that your estate does not require a trust; in many situations, having a properly prepared will is perfectly acceptable. A will is enough to manage your estate when:

• Your estate is small
• All your property is located within the same state or province
• You have all adult beneficiaries who are financially independent
• Your desire for privacy has less importance than having a will
• You do not need someone else to handle anything related to your estate once you pass away

There isn’t much value in adding unnecessary complexity with a trust. Just as it is risky to build too complex an estate plan, it is also very dangerous to underestimate the amount of planning needed. It’s recommended that you review your estate plan, regardless of how simple it seems, at least periodically.

When a Trust Becomes Essential

A trust is increasingly important when there is a need to make ongoing distributions of assets within an estate. For example:

• Cross-border estate planning (where the estate includes assets/beneficiaries located in multiple jurisdictions)
• Business succession planning with respect to company shareholding
• Asset protection concerns, including potential litigation or creditor exposure
• Providing long-term financial assistance to minors or vulnerable individuals
• Keeping family affairs private by avoiding publicity associated with public probate records

Trusts have become very popular among estate planning practitioners in many common law jurisdictions, including the UK, USA, and Australia; however, because each country has its own laws regarding trusts, their application can vary greatly between jurisdictions.

Such examples include:

• Taxation of trusts under U.S. Federal Income Tax Law is governed by separate rules depending on whether a trust is considered “revocable” or “irrevocable.”
• Transparency provisions related to the CRS (Common Reporting Standard) adopted by the OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation & Development) govern disclosure requirements relating to cross-border financial assets held in trust.
• Beneficial ownership transparency standards set by the FATF (Financial Action Task Force) may directly affect how trusts report required information about their beneficial owners.

Therefore, trusts are often viewed as estate planning tools. However, they also serve as governance/compliance structures in many cross-border estate planning situations.

Why Most Strong Estate Plans Use Both a Trust and a Will

Most individuals believe that simply establishing a trust signifies that a will is unnecessary. However, many of the best and most comprehensive estate plans establish both trusts and wills.

Typically, a will acts as a “backup” for those assets/property that were not explicitly placed into the trust and for potential issues involving child or adult guardianship, which may have been established through a trust; however, there are often legal ramifications associated with these latter issues that cannot be addressed solely through a trust. Therefore, utilizing both trusts and wills provides certainty that each component of an individual’s estate plan has been adequately provided for.

Benefits of this dual-document approach include:

• Clarification of your wishes regarding your personal affairs
• Complete coverage of all of your assets
• Prevention of unintentional gaps in your planning

By employing this layered-planning technique, you can better reflect how estate planning truly occurs — circumstances are constantly evolving, and no single document can ever anticipate every possibility.

Alternatively, if your situation is more complex, you can always contact one of Q Wealth advisors to see a range of options and choose the one that works for you. That said, one of the most popular options amongst our clients is a Nevis offshore trust.

Real-Life Example: How a Trust and Will Work Together 

To see how trusts and wills work together practically, think about someone who has UK-based property and investments abroad and/or shares in a private company and also has two children, with one of them still being underage. This individual would need a combination of short-term assistance in making decisions about how to distribute their estate, along with longer-term advice on managing their overall asset base.

The will could include details concerning the appointment of a guardian for minors, direct the manner in which the remainder of the estate should be distributed, and identify who should act as executor for the estate. In every jurisdiction, assets that are subject to a Will must go through Probate prior to passing to beneficiaries, according to rules set out by HM Courts & Tribunals Service in England and Wales (and/or equivalent)

Conversely, a trust will allow for ongoing management and control of:

• Business interest operations
• Administration of assets in case of incapacity
• Distribution of money over time
• Probate exemption for certain assets when permitted by law

In this case, the trust will be responsible for providing continuing direction and control over the administration of the assets. The will will address questions relating to guardianship of minors and any assets not included within the scope of the trust. Together, they will provide a much broader plan for administering an individual’s estate than if each were used separately, thereby reducing gaps in ownership, control, and intended outcome.

Common Estate Planning Mistakes with Trusts and Wills

The majority of estate planning problems do not come from poor intentions on the part of individuals; rather, they most commonly stem from unproven assumptions that have gone unchecked and unresolved for far too long. Paperwork looks great, but when it comes down to it, those gaps will normally present themselves at the worst possible time.

A few common errors are:

1. Believing a will works through probate. Probate is an inherent component of how wills work. Regardless of how straightforward an estate appears, there will always be some form of probate involved.
2. Creating a trust but never funding it. A trust with no assets is simply theory vs. reality. With this type of setup, you will receive little to no protection or control.
3. Not taking into account cross-border issues. When your beneficiaries, family members, or asset owners reside in different countries, local laws can supersede original expectations if you did not plan for them soon enough.
4. Selecting legal documents before figuring out your goals. The structure should serve a purpose (and vice versa). Without clearly defined objectives, advanced setups may still miss the mark.
5. Not reviewing documents over time. As we know, life rarely remains static. Marriage, children, moving, new assets, etc.; plans that are not regularly reviewed have a tendency to age poorly.

A Practical Decision Framework: Trust or Will?

As opposed to simply asking yourself which legal document(s) you wish to utilize, you can also start by asking yourself several questions as you initiate this process:

1. Will I have a say in how my property is treated after I pass away (and/or who it goes to)?
2. Are there family members or other beneficiaries living in multiple countries?
3. Am I worried about keeping my privacy private from other people?
4. Have I accumulated assets/money/beneficiaries in multiple countries/jurisdictions, and do you believe this could become problematic for my heirs when they try to navigate the probate system?
5. Do you feel that there will be many changes throughout your estate while you are alive?

By answering these questions, you can determine whether a will covers all your objectives or whether you need to consider establishing a trust.

How Estate Planning Looks in Practice, Not Theory

Much of the confusion about trusts and wills stems from theoretical applications that are not reflective of actual practice. Practically speaking, estate planning exists where legal systems intersect with bank-related needs, family dynamics, and operational longevity.

In practice, while trusts and wills may look simple enough on paper as legal documents, if they cannot be executed by banks (and/or other counterparts) in a functional manner based upon documentation compliance with regulatory and risk requirements, then the technical merit of a trust/will is irrelevant. Therefore, in most cases, structures that require extensive justification and/or unclear governance models are subject to delay(s) or further review despite being technically correct.

Thus, why experienced advisors prioritize simplicity, structure, and implementation for estates (over unnecessary complexity) is because of the need to have trust-based wills that actually operate within the boundaries of banking requirements, trustee onboarding procedures, international administrative practices, etc., such that the structuring of assets is both legally viable and practically applicable.

Conclusion: Trust vs Will Is Not a Competition

A will and a trust are not rivals, and estate planning is about more than choosing between them.

A will provides order and closure. A trust adds structure, continuity, and the ability to make changes as your needs evolve. It does not matter which name you give these documents. What matters is whether or not they accomplish your goals.

Some people have simple needs, while others require greater flexibility and longer-term control. The majority of individuals fall somewhere in-between. Generally speaking, most effective estate plans are those that are reasonable, rather than perfect. Reasonable plans are created with real families, real assets, and real change in mind.

Ultimately, estate planning is not about creating forms. Ultimately, estate planning is about ensuring that the end result makes sense when you are no longer involved.

Frequently Asked Questions