Can a Cook Islands Asset Protection Trust Protect Assets in Divorce?

Divorce puts many years’ worth of accumulated wealth at risk—particularly when large sums have been invested in businesses, international properties, and other assets. If properly set up and administered, a Cook Islands asset protection trust can offer highly effective protection against future divorce-related claims; however, the court will not ignore this type of trust simply because one party has entered into a dispute with their spouse over marital property. The court could disregard the transfer of funds or other types of property into the trust after the parties enter into a dispute over their marriage. Moreover, if there is any indication of fraud or of an attempt by either party to avoid their legally enforceable obligation, the court will consider such actions part of a larger fraudulent scheme.

The ability of a Cook Islands trust to protect your assets will depend upon a number of elements. These include when you created the trust, where the assets originated, whether they were transferred to the trust prior to any foreseeable claim on them, as well as other aspects we will explore in this article.

Key Takeaways

• Assets placed in a Cook Islands trust will have greater protection against being taken in a divorce proceeding, provided that the assets were moved into the trust before any marital issues arose or any foreign court proceedings began.
• The Cook Islands is among the jurisdictions with the most protective legal framework for protecting assets abroad, which would generally make it very difficult for an asset located outside the country (i.e., in a trust) to be subject to enforcement by foreign courts based on foreign court judgments.
• Transferring assets into a trust provides the greatest protection from lawsuits and/or divorces once such a lawsuit or divorce becomes reasonably likely.
• There are still some potential avenues through which a court could void a trust created to avoid or conceal liability for past debts/obligations or to fraudulently move assets out of the reach of creditors.
• A Cook Islands trust should be part of a broader wealth-preservation and estate-planning strategy rather than a last-minute solution in divorce proceedings.

Why Cook Islands Trusts Are Used for Divorce Asset Protection

While many U.S.-based trusts that offer asset protection may still be reachable by creditors through state court judgments, the Cook Islands has enacted special legislation to significantly strengthen its ability to provide international asset protection.

The Cook Islands law governing most Cook Islands trusts is set out in the Cook Islands International Trusts Act 1984 and provides the basis for much of the foreign judgment treatment and asset separation protections referred to throughout this paper.

Unlike the use of contracts alone or simply using the laws of your domicile to protect your assets, a Cook Islands trust removes the beneficial owner (the individual whose income can produce the funds needed to pay future creditor claims) from the legal title to the assets placed in it. When the assets are properly placed in a Cook Islands trust, the settlor no longer owns them, but instead, they are owned by an independent trustee who does not receive distributions from those assets.

One reason Cook Islands trusts have become so popular among high-risk litigators (entrepreneurs, investors, doctors, attorneys, etc.) is the clear distinction between the beneficial owner of the assets and the person with legal title to them.

What Makes Cook Islands Law Different?

The Cook Islands’ strong reputation is due to a number of legal protections that differentiate it from most other offshore jurisdictions.

Key features include:

These various legal safeguards combine to provide some of the best legal asset protection available. However, while these legal protections will substantially reduce potential liability, they do not necessarily prevent all legal claims. All trustee services in this jurisdiction are subject to regulation by the Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission, and as such, all licensed service providers in the jurisdiction must comply with regulatory and corporate governance rules.

Why Divorce Can Put Personal Wealth at Risk

High-net-worth divorces do not simply involve splitting the marital home or dividing your bank account. Entrepreneurs and international families will need to be concerned with protecting their business and other investments, trusts, pension funds, cryptocurrency, and foreign property.

Courts in a large number of countries have considerable latitude when deciding how to equitably divide all of an individual’s assets that comprise their marital estate. This decision-making power typically extends to longer-married couples who share dependent children.

The laws regarding the division of marital assets vary from country to country. However, regardless of the jurisdiction, courts tend to follow similar guidelines, which include the following:

• When was each asset purchased?
• Are these assets considered “separate” or “marital” property?
• What financial contributions did both spouses make towards acquiring the assets?
• What future financial requirements are needed by each spouse?
• Do any existing agreements exist between the spouses, i.e., a prenup/postnup?

It is this uncertainty that has led some high-net-worth individuals to develop asset protection strategies well before any potential marital disputes arise.

Separate Property vs Marital Property

One of the biggest misunderstandings in divorce law is the difference between “separate” property and “marital” (or “community”) property.

Generally speaking, separate property often includes:

• Assets owned before marriage;
• Inheritances;
• Certain gifts received individually.

Marital property typically includes:

• Income you earn while you’re married,
• Investments that both spouses acquire together,
• Businesses you develop together while you’re married,
• Real estate you buy together.

Again, though, how each jurisdiction defines and treats marital vs. separate property varies greatly. If assets were originally deemed “your separate” property, they could be converted to marital property depending on whether they were commingled with other jointly held assets or co-managed for an extended period.

TRUSTS & FOUNDATIONS
FREE CONSULTATION

on offshore structures and jurisdictions
that would best meet your
asset protection goals.

on offshore structures and jurisdictions that would best meet your asset protection goals.

We’ll contact you in 10 minutes

CLICK TO
BOOK CLICK TO
BOOK

We’ll contact you in 10 minutes

Can a Cook Islands Trust Protect Assets During Divorce?

The simple answer to this question is “yes,” but only if you do everything right. The best way a Cook Islands trust will protect your assets during a divorce is by being part of your overall financial plan — not just something you establish during divorce litigation.

Situations Where Protection Is More Likely

Protection of your Cook Islands Trust may be much greater in situations where:

• You set up the trust prior to entering into a marital relationship or at least long enough before you knew there could potentially be a divorce;
• You transferred assets to the trust prior to any legal disputes arising;
• Your trustee acts independently;
• Records kept by the trust clearly indicate that the trust has been properly administered;
• There has been full compliance with all tax laws and reporting obligations (as required by international disclosure regimes, e.g., the OECD CRS and FinCEN FBAR). This demonstrates that the purpose of the trust is to properly protect your assets for both current use and future generations, rather than to thwart one spouse’s claims against the other.

Situations Where Protection May Fail

On the other hand, the protection afforded by a Cook Islands trust will be very weak in cases where:

• You transfer assets to the trust after you and your spouse are separated;
• Divorce court proceedings have begun;
• Court orders regarding the distribution of Assets have been entered;
• Transfers were made so that you would not have to pay what you reasonably expect to have to pay as part of your settlement;
• The person who established the trust (i.e., the settlor) maintains actual control over the trust assets.

Practical Examples

These examples illustrate why experienced advisers consistently emphasize that successful asset protection begins long before litigation or divorce becomes a realistic possibility.

What Courts Look at When Reviewing a Cook Islands Trust

The courts view overseas trusts as being completely beyond their jurisdiction. In addition, the courts will analyze what prompted the creation of the trust. Was it a genuine, planned approach by the settlor? Or was the creation of the trust in direct response to either an existing or anticipated dispute?

• Time of creation: How far in advance did the settlor create the trust prior to the breakdown of his/her relationships?
• Assets that comprise the trust: Are the assets within the trust premarital, inheritances, or joint assets acquired during the marriage?
• Independence of trustee: Does the trustee have actual control over the assets, or does the settlor continue to directly manage them?
• Reasons for making transfers into the trust: Were these made pursuant to long-term plans, or were they made with intent to circumvent obligations that existed prior to the transfer into the trust?
• Compliance with applicable laws/regulations: Is the trust fully disclosed to all required parties, and is it compliant with any/all applicable tax laws/regulations and reporting requirements (if any)?

A well-documented and properly administered trust is typically viewed more favorably by the court than one created in anticipation of ongoing or pending litigation.

Factors That Determine Whether Protection Is Effective

Each divorce case has its own unique circumstances and characteristics that can impact how well a Cook Islands Trust works. The strength of a Cook Islands trust depends on many interrelated elements, not just a single legal provision.

• Timing before marriage: Establishing an asset protection trust typically provides stronger protection when done before marriage, because there will be documentation showing it was included in your long-term plans. The establishment of trusts by entrepreneurs, small business owners, and people entering a second marriage with some pre-existing wealth is very common.
• Timing before divorce: If you establish an asset protection trust while you are married and the marriage is still intact, it could offer some level of protection. However, at the time you separate from your spouse, and certainly after proceedings commence, transferring assets to a trust is much more likely to be challenged, most notably on the basis of fraudulent conveyancing.
• Type of assets used to fund the trust: There is a considerable difference based upon where the assets came from. Assets owned individually prior to marriage, assets received through inheritance, and assets acquired together while married are all subject to different considerations. Additionally, assets such as business interests may need to be independently appraised to be fairly divided.
• Accurate funding and ongoing administration: In addition to the above factors, a trust will only be considered successful if funds are appropriately placed into it and administered in accordance with the terms outlined within the trust document (i.e., the trust deed). Documentation of all decisions made by the trustee(s), including complete records of every transaction performed in the course of administering the trust and compliance with all aspects of the trust document itself, would help ensure that it is viewed as an actual legal entity rather than simply a paper exercise.

Advantages of Using a Cook Islands Trust for Divorce Protection

When used as part of an overall financial plan, a Cook Islands trust can have several advantages over time with regard to the protection of your family’s wealth. These can include:

• Asset protection that will protect you and your family from creditors now and in the future;
• Protecting your wealth for the next generation (i.e., estate planning);
• Flexibility regarding how your estate is distributed after death;
• Increased privacy compared to holding personal property in other countries;
• Continuing management of your wealth if you become incapacitated;
• Ability to move your wealth to various locations around the world, depending upon where your business interests take you.

It is worth noting that all of the above advantages result from forward thinking, not from doing things at the last minute.

Risks and Practical Considerations

Although Cook Islands trusts are among the best offshore asset protection tools, there isn’t an “off-the-shelf” solution that fits every individual. The key consideration when evaluating the suitability of Cook Islands trusts will be the relative pros versus cons.

• Costs: Establishing and managing a trust requires professional drafting of documents, trustee fees, and various administrative costs; as such, it is usually cost-effective only for higher-value assets.
• Compliance with Regulations: Offshore trusts are subject to increasing regulatory scrutiny and transparency globally. This includes tax reporting requirements (i.e., Form W-8BEN), beneficial owner disclosure, anti-money laundering obligations, and participation in international cooperation to combat money laundering. Failure to comply with these regulations could result in substantial fines.
• Tax Considerations: The primary purpose of establishing a Cook Islands trust is asset protection, not tax avoidance. As such, the tax implications associated with establishing or funding the trust depend on the settlor’s residency or citizenship status. Therefore, obtaining professional tax guidance prior to establishing the trust/structure is crucial.

Cook Islands Trust vs Other Divorce Asset Protection Strategies

There is no one-size-fits-all planning strategy that will protect your assets in divorce. Most families are multigenerational and face multiple financial challenges; therefore, most wealth plans combine a range of planning tools.

Rather than seeing other strategies as competitors, most strategies can be used together. Some might even want to consider alternative jurisdictions, for example, Nevis. Nevertheless, a well-drafted prenuptial agreement along with a well-administered Cook Islands trust would likely give you greater asset protection than using only one of those strategies.

Best Practices for Building a Divorce-Resistant Asset Protection Strategy

If you are looking to create a Cook Islands trust, do not use it as a way to quickly protect your money. It is part of your long-term financial plan.

The best ways to build this type of long-term financial plan include the following:

• Create the trust in advance of a dispute over legal issues.
• Only transfer funds into the trust once you have received guidance from both a lawyer and a tax professional.
• Select an independent trustee who has experience with trusts.
• Keep good, up-to-date records of how the trust is being administered.
• Fully comply with all tax and financial report requirements.
• Regularly review your trust as your family’s situation and your finances change.
• Coordinate your trust with your estate plans (including wills), your succession plans, and any other prenuptial or post-nuptial agreements you may be entering into.

By building on these recommendations, you can continue to protect your assets through an offshore asset protection plan.

Summary

A Cook Islands asset protection trust could provide substantial protection for your wealth against potential future divorce-related claims; however, it’s only truly effective when you proactively plan (rather than reactively adjust) this form of asset protection. The strength of a Cook Islands asset protection trust is directly affected by several key elements, including the timing of the transfer, the independence of the trustee(s), the proper transfer of assets, and compliance with regulations governing continued operation. 

No matter how strong the Cook Islands legislation may be in providing a framework for protecting assets abroad, courts will ultimately review all the circumstances of each case, especially if transfers were made during or after marital discord. Therefore, the most efficient method for those with considerable amounts of money is to include the creation of an asset protection trust within a broader strategy that addresses both long-term and short-term needs associated with estate planning, taxation, and marital contracts (where appropriate).

Frequently Asked Questions